Menu of Alessio Pizzeria in New Hyde Park, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Alessio Pizzeria, nestled at 2054 Lakeville Rd in New Hyde Park, NY, is a compelling destination for authentic pizza lovers and casual diners alike. This establishment’s menu offers a robust variety, balancing classic New York-style staples with creative twists, making it a standout in the regional pizza scene.

The menu highlights immediately draw attention with items like the Garlic Knot, a perfect starter that showcases masterful bread preparation—soft, buttery, and kissed with just the right amount of garlic and herbs. Their pizza slices, particularly the Pepperoni Pizza Slice and the Margarita Pizza, exemplify true artisanal flavors. The sauce, often praised by regulars, sings with a perfect balance of acidity and herbs, anchoring each bite of the thin, yet tender crust. This is where Alessio’s signature artistry shines through, as noted in the heartfelt customer reviews praising the sauce’s remarkable quality.

For those craving heartier options, the menu’s Meat Lovers Pizza and Chicken Alla Vodka Pizza offer rich, savory indulgence, layered with premium toppings like sausage, meatballs, chicken, and aromatic peppers. Vegetarians aren’t left behind; choices such as the Mix Vegetables Pizza, White Pizza, and the deliciously fresh Vegetable Minestrone Soup provide nourishing and flavorful alternatives.

The variety in their round pies—offered in both traditional 18" sizes and pizzettas at 12"—allows for customizable experiences. Toppings range widely from classic pepperoni and mushrooms to more unique selections like broccoli rabe and eggplant. The cauliflower crust pizza stands out as a thoughtful nod toward health-conscious diners seeking gluten-sensitive options without sacrificing flavor.

Beyond pizzas, Alessio’s rolls, calzones, wraps, and paninis display an impressive range. The Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap and the Chicken Club Panini have garnered attention for their fresh ingredients and satisfying textures. These handheld choices reflect Alessio’s dedication to quality beyond pizza, appealing to customers looking for a complete meal or a quick bite.

Customer feedback echoes the consistency and care Alessio Pizzeria puts into every dish. Patrons like Michael V. commend the restaurant’s clean, organized environment and credit the distinctive sauce as key to their loyalty. Meanwhile, Gorden Ye highlights the juicy, perfectly cooked barbecue wings and fresh sides—demonstrating that Alessio’s excels even in its non-pizza offerings. First-timers such as Daniel Soto describe pleasantly surprised devotion after trying the chicken wrap, emphasizing the restaurant’s ability to convert skeptics.

The value proposition is another compelling reason to visit. CoPilot PSS applauds the unbeatable deal of two genuine New York-sized cheese slices and a soda for just under seven dollars, coupled with attentive and friendly customer service. The warm reception from staff members like Alex and Oscar enhances the overall dining experience, making customers feel welcome and informed about the menu.

Lastly, Alessio Pizzeria’s commitment to cleanliness and customer comfort cannot be overstated. Crystal Lilly appreciates the well-maintained space, convenient amenities, and quick, fresh food service—making it not merely a stop for pizza but a comfortable environment for eating in or grabbing a quick meal.

In conclusion, Alessio Pizzeria’s menu is a harmonious blend of tradition and innovation, delivering consistently flavorful dishes with a heartfelt nod to community and quality. Whether you’re seeking an iconic New York slice, a hearty panini, or a fresh vegetable-packed wrap, Alessio stands ready to impress with every bite.